Choose Your QB: Peyton Manning vs. Aaron Rodgers

Today's installment of Choose Your Quarterback pits Aaron Rodgers vs. Peyton Manning, the Nos. 1 and 3 assets in my rankings of the 32 presumed starting quarterbacks.

Here's a week-by-week fantasy breakdown of Manning vs. Rodgers, just in case you're torn on which quarterback to grab in Round 1:

Week 1—Manning (vs. Baltimore) over Rodgers (@ San Francisco)
Week 2—Manning (@ N.Y. Giants) over Rodgers (vs. Washington)
Week 3—Manning (vs. Oakland) over Rodgers (@ Cincinnati)
Week 4—Manning (vs. Philadelphia) over Rodgers (BYE)
Week 5—Rodgers (vs. Detroit) over Manning (@ Dallas)
Week 6—Manning (vs. Jacksonville) over Rodgers (@ Baltimore)
Week 7—Manning (@ Indianapolis) over Rodgers (vs. Cleveland)
Week 8—Rodgers (@ Minnesota) over Manning (vs. Washington)
Week 9—Rodgers (vs. Chicago) over Manning (BYE)
Week 10—Rodgers (vs. Philadelphia) over Manning (@ San Diego)
Week 11—Rodgers (@ N.Y. Giants) over Manning (vs. Kansas City)
Week 12—Manning (@ New England) over Rodgers (vs. Minnesota)
Week 13—Rodgers (@ Detroit) over Manning (@ Kansas City)
Week 14—Rodgers (vs. Atlanta) over Manning (vs. Tennessee)
Week 15—Manning (vs. San Diego) over Rodgers (@ Dallas)
Week 16—Rodgers (vs. Pittsburgh) over Manning (@ Houston)
Week 17—Manning (@ Oakland) over Rodgers (@ Chicago)